Fire Island Real Estate · Licensed Since 2014

Over 100 Fire Island sales since 2015.

I represent buyers and sellers across Ocean Beach, Ocean Bay Park, Seaview, and Corneille Estates. 108+ closed transactions, $157M+ in volume since 2015. Third-generation Fire Islander. Straight answers, every time.

Free · In writing · 48-hour turnaround · No obligation

108+
Closed transactions since 2015
$157M+
Represented volume
20+
Years of proprietary Fire Island sales data
3rd
Generation · Family in the market since the 1950s
Recent Transactions

I represented the buyer, seller or both on these recent deals.

Ocean Beach property, cedar shingle home Ocean Beach
Ocean Beach property with pool Ocean Beach
Ocean Beach two-story shingled home with pool Ocean Beach
Modern Fire Island home, aerial view with multi-level decks Ocean Beach
How I Represent Buyers

A process built around straight answers, not pressure.

Access

Every listing on Fire Island, plus a meaningful share of off-market homes you won’t see anywhere else.

Background

Years of investment and construction experience. I’ll show you what a property can actually become, and what it really costs to own.

Data

A proprietary Fire Island sales database going back to 2006. Two decades of comps that sharpen every offer I help write.

01 · Discovery

We talk.

A 20-minute call to understand what you’re looking for, what you can spend, and what actually matters to you on Fire Island.

02 · Briefing

I brief you on the market.

Current inventory, seasonality, community tradeoffs, what $X actually buys in Ocean Beach vs. Ocean Bay Park vs. Seaview vs. Corneille Estates.

03 · The Tour

The Tour.

A few hours together is all it takes. Fire Island is small enough that we can usually see every property in your range in a single afternoon, the full market, in one shot.

04 · Close

We negotiate and close.

With the analysis in hand, you’re negotiating from facts, not feelings. And you’ll know exactly what you’re buying.

Why Clients Pick Me

Three reasons, no fluff.

I give you real numbers.

You’ll know what a house actually costs to own before you sign anything. Taxes, insurance, flood premiums, maintenance, what it rents for in July. Not vibes. Not comps from three years ago. The numbers.

I know what’s behind the walls.

Years of developing and renovating on Fire Island. I see the permit history, the foundation, the roof, the staging tricks. When I walk a house with you, I’m not just showing it. I’m reading it.

My family’s been here since the 1950s.

Third generation. 70+ years of institutional market knowledge, inherited. The blocks, the families, the flood history, the rebuilds. That’s the lens I bring to your search. It’s not something anyone else on the island can offer.

Current Listings

What I’m showing this week.

A live look at the homes I’m representing on Fire Island. Want my honest take on any of them? Just ask.

Open full search on OneKey MLS
About Alan

A life spent on every side of this island.

I grew up summering on Fire Island. My grandparents founded our family real estate business here in the 1950s. My mother ran it after them.

In my 20s, I did two things: I got my real estate license in 2014, and my sister and I opened the Fire Island Ice Cream Co. in Ocean Beach. Entrepreneurship has been in the DNA from the start.

I’d been investing in Fire Island real estate for years by then. Since 2015, representing buyers and sellers has been my focus. Today I make my home in Seaview with my wife and two kids.

I’ve been through Hurricane Sandy, the 2020 buying frenzy, the 2022 peak, and the rate-driven slowdown that followed. Same approach the whole way through: tell the truth, walk the house with my eyes open, earn the next one.

$729K
2015 avg sale price
$3.34M
2022 avg sale price
11+
Years actively representing buyers and sellers
Read the full story
The Firm

I’m a partner at Fire Island Sales & Rentals, the largest brokerage on the island. Founded by my grandparents in the 1950s, run today by my sister Abi and me.

Visit fisr.com
The Offer

What’s your Fire Island
home worth?

A free, written valuation of your Fire Island home: comps, condition notes, rental potential, what I’d recommend you list at. In your inbox in 48 hours. No obligation, no pressure to sign with me.

Not ready to buy yet? Get the newsletter for weekly notes on the Fire Island market, from someone who actually works it.